Tuesday 23 October 2012

Malignaggi vs Cano - Press And Fan Scores

Over the last few days i have been collecting scores for the Malignaggi vs Cano fight which took place at the Barclay's Centre in Brooklyn New York. Respected Boxing writer Thomas Hauser sent an e-mail asking if i covered the fight. I sent an e-mail back saying that i didn't cover the fight but it would be an honour to do so as i think Thomas wrote the best ever book i have read "ALI - His Life and Times.

Below are my findings on the Malignaggi vs Cano fight. A close fight that i feel could have went either way. Watching the fight i feel that there could have been at least 4-5 rounds that could have been scored for each boxer. This fightIi DONT was not a ROBBERY because of the many close rounds.. I was able to collect OVER 100 scores from the Press and Fans but i have also put my scorecard up for scrutiny.

MY SCORECARD

Round 1 : 10-9 Malignaggi
Round 2 : 10-9 Malignaggi
Round 3 : 9-10 Cano
Round 4 : 9-10 Cano
Round 5 : 10-10 Draw
Round 6 : 9-10 Cano
Round 7 : 10-9 Malignaggi
Round 8 : 9-10 Cano
Round 9 : 10-9 Malignaggi
Round 10: 10-9 Malignaggi
Round 11: 8-10 Cano
Round 12: 9-10 Cano

TOTAL : 115-113 Cano



The Final Results Were :


PRESS : 29 scores , 19 for Cano , 8 for Malignaggi , 2 a Draw


FANS: 80 scores , 59 for Cano , 21 for Malignaggi


TOTAL: 109 scores , 78 for Cano , 29 for Malignaggi , 2 a Draw



Here is The Press And Fans Scores Taken From Twitter And The Best Boxing Forums Around.


Matthew Mojica (Fightsource) : 114-113 Cano

Dan Rafael (ESPN) : 115-112 Cano

Mark Ortega (The Queensbury Rules) : 115-112 Cano

Tom Gray (Secondsout.com) : 115-112 Cano

Ernest Gabion (The Boxing Lab) : 114-113 Malignaggi

Scott Smith (UK Fighthype) : 114-113 Malignaggi

Jake Donovan (Boxingscene) : 115-112 Cano

Paddy Cronan (Onthegrindboxing) : 115-113 Cano

Kieran Mulvaney (ESPN) : 115-112 Cano

Darren Velasco (Fightdomain) : 114-113 Cano

Scott Christ (Badlefthook) : 115-112 Cano

Jenna Jay (Ontheropesboxing) : 114-113 Malignaggi

Kevin Iole (Yahoo.com) : 114-113 Malignaggi

Joshua McDaniel (Leaveitinthering) : 114-113 Malignaggi

Ryan Burton (The Boxing Lab) : 114-113 Malignaggi

BoxingOpinions.com : 115-114 Cano

Matt Christie (Boxingnews ) : 114-114 Draw

Steve Lillis (Boxnation) : 114-114 Draw

BoxingSocialist.com : 114-113 Malignaggi

Phil D Jay (Worldboxingnews.net) : 114-113 Cano

Boxing.com : 115-112 Cano

Billy Ferguson (UK fIghthype) : 114-113 Cano

Nigel Collins (ESPN) : 114-113 Cano

Cliff Roid (Boxingscene) : 114-113 Malignaggi

FightGhost : 114-113 Cano

Al Bernstein (Showtime) : 116-112 Cano

Steve Farhood (Showtime) : 115-112 Cano

Austin Trout (Showtime) : 114-113 Cano

Barry Tomkins (Showtime) : 114-113 Cano

SaddoBoxing Forum : 116-111 x2, 115-112 Cano ,* *114-113 Malignaggi**

BoxingAsylum Forum : 115-112 x4, 114-113 x3, 116-111 , 114-112 All for Cano
                                        **114-113 Malgnaggi**

Livefight Forum : 116-111 Cano

Fightjudge Forum : 116-111 x2, 117-110 x2, 115-112 , 116-111, 118-109 All for Cano
                                ** 115-113 Malignaggi**

Doghouseboxing Forum : 115-112 x2 All for Cano

Thesweetscience Forum : **114-113 x2 All for Malignaggi**

Boxrec Forum : 115-112 x5, 114-113 x2, 116-111 x2 , 116-114, 118-109 All for Cano
                          ** 114-113 x4 , 115-114 All for Malignaggi**

Eastsideboxing Forum : 114-113, x4, 115-112 x3, 116-111 x3, 116-112, 115-113, 119-108 Cano
                                       ** 114-113 x3 Malignaggi **

Boxingscene Forum : 114-113 x5, 115 -112 x4, 116-111 All for Cano
                                    **114-113 x6 Malignaggi**

Checkhookboxing Forum : 115-114 x2, 115-112 All for Cano
                                           ** 114-113 x2, 115-113 All for Malignaggi**

Pawel + Per Plex (twitter fans) : 117-110 Cano , 114-113 Cano




No comments:

Post a Comment